Sonic 3D - Diamond Dust (PRC122)
Votes (5)
Jun 15, 2008
bundeslang
-
Snow in July
Rexy -
All That Glitters
Binweasel -
Dusty Diamonds
munchi
Chickenwarlord - The song misses variation, the wholse song is boring. But, my ears are still here, it's not so bad.
Binweasel - Interesting start, but after a while the samples become boring. I like the middle part, it's well mixed. The samples are the same during the whole song.
Rexy - I like the samples you used at the start, I don't like the drumline, it's a little dominating. The middle section is nice. The last minute isn't, because it's the same as before. Good end.
Jun 15, 2008
munchi
-
Snow in July
Rexy -
Just Coal
Chickenwarlord -
All That Glitters
Binweasel
Chicken: I'm noticing a pattern here. You submit an entry and then I say, "I think the compositional elements and overall feel of the song are spot on, and then I say if you used slightly better samples and a little more time mastering this would be first place hands down." Well, I don't want to mess with tradition so read what's in the quotes again.
Binweasel: I happen to be a low brass player at heart and I'm telling you that I would love to play your song. You get third not so much because of issues with your song. It's just in comparison with the other two, I have to vote you third. But honestly, it's a real solid piece (especially for a rush job!)
Jun 16, 2008
kylenin
-
Snow in July
Rexy -
Dusty Diamonds
munchi -
All That Glitters
Binweasel
Jun 16, 2008
Chickenwarlord
-
Snow in July
Rexy -
Dusty Diamonds
munchi -
All That Glitters
Binweasel
Munchi's Brass hits were a bit distracting from the rest of the arrangement. :31 stood out in particular as jarring.
Binweasel: Your song sound the most cluttered. Especially that powerful drum line. Really takes out the bass. The brass aren't as bad as last time.
Jun 17, 2008
Binweasel
-
Snow in July
Rexy -
Dusty Diamonds
munchi -
Just Coal
Chickenwarlord
2. Much like the previous one, quite pretty and some very nice stuff around the first half. 2:02 especially made me grin. Unfortunately it kinda falls flat around my favourite bits, where the sax kicks in, in the original.
3. I very much enjoyed the sort of burbly wosscalled, like western/cowboy sort of thing going on, and the slightly slower pace than the others. The lack of drums rather helped, I think. But again, just barely 30 seconds of the part of the song I actually liked...